Quantcast

Why Supremes Let Texas Abortion Law Stand

Opinion by Henry Olsen

THE WASHINGTON POST – The Supreme Court’s 5-to-4 refusal to grant a preliminary injunction to prevent operation of Texas’s law banning abortion after a fetal heartbeat can be detected has unleashed a squall of public debate over abortion law.

While that furor won’t calm for months or more, one thing is clear: The court’s majority was legally correct.

Courts are not legislatures. They are frequently mistaken by many, including many lawyers, as bodies vested with plenary power to examine social problems and devise novel solutions.

But a court can only act if there is an identifiable defendant whose acts could cause an identifiable plaintiff harm contrary to law.

Most legislatures that have sought to limit legal abortion contrary to Roe v. Wade have run afoul of this because the laws they passed made the state the agent of enforcement.

...article continued below
- Advertisement -

The state could thus be enjoined by a court from enforcing the law given its presumptive unconstitutionality.

The Texas law, however, avoids this by placing the exclusive authority to enforce the law in the hands of private citizens who could sue abortion providers in civil actions. Therefore, there are no governmental defendants who have the power to harm.

The abortion providers in this case sued people and groups that might be involved in the enforcement process, such as trial judges and Mark Lee Dickson, director of Right to Life East Texas, who has called for people to sue abortion providers.

But enjoining these defendants still would not remove their potential harm.

The court therefore could not have granted any relief that could forestall the alleged harms to the abortion providers, as my colleague at the Ethics and Public Policy Center, Ed Whelan, has clearly demonstrated.

...article continued below
- Advertisement -

The court majority saw this issue clearly. It wrote:

“Federal courts enjoy the power to enjoin individuals tasked with enforcing laws, not the laws themselves … ”

 

- Advertisement -

TRENDING

Game-Changing Covid Treatment Pill May Be Just Months Away

At least three promising antivirals for covid are being tested in clinical trials, with results expected as soon as late fall or winter.

U.S. Is Discarding Millions Of Doses Of Unwanted Vaccines

The federal government is working with Covid-19 vaccine manufacturers to reduce the number of doses per vial, amid growing concerns about wasted vaccines.

Pop Star Makes Stunning Discovery: ‘People Are Scared Of Big Boobs’

“I lost 100,000 followers, just because of the boobs. People are scared of big boobs.”

Vaccinated People Are ‘Just as Likely’ to Spread Covid: True?

The Atlantic – For many fully vaccinated Americans, the Delta surge spoiled what should’ve been a glorious summer. Those who had cast their masks aside...

Biden Admin. Awards $150K To Florida District That Resisted DeSantis

WASHINGTON — The Biden administration said on Thursday that it was reimbursing a Florida school district that lost state money for imposing a mask...

Ivermectin: What The Evidence Says

Daily Briefing, September 21, 2021 ADVISORY BOARD – Ivermectin is an anti-parasite drug discovered in 1975. It was initially introduced as a drug for livestock,...

CDC Backs COVID Booster For Millions

AP – The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention on Thursday endorsed booster shots for millions of older or otherwise vulnerable Americans, opening a...

Doctors Charged In Massive Fraud Including False Covid Claims

NBC NEWS – The Department of Justice has announced criminal charges against 42 medical professionals, including 23 doctors, and nearly 100 other people for...

Middle-School Mom Rips School Board Over Anal Sex Reference

FOX NEWS – A Texas school district has removed a book from schools after an irate mother read aloud an excerpt about anal sex...

State Cops Sue Governor To Block Vaccine Mandate

FOX NEWS – The union that represents about 1,800 Massachusetts State Police troopers went before a judge Wednesday asking for a delay in the...
- Advertisement -